Guillermo del Toro accused of stealing plot for his Golden-Globe …
Back to IndieWire
‘Desire’ Netflix Controversy: Director Diego Kaplan Defends His Film Against Accusations of Child Pornography
The filmmaker told IndieWire that the scene, which a conservative news site reported to the FBI, was filmed “under the careful surveillance of the girls’ mothers.”
Jun 30, 2018 10:00 am
- Share This Article
Netflix is facing backlash from users online over the Argentinian film “ Desire ,” which opens with a scene involving a young girl accidentally having her first orgasm. The scene is being accused on social media of featuring child pornography, but director Diego Kaplan told IndieWire that’s not the case. The filmmaker said the child actor was never exploited on set and the scene was filmed “under the surveillance” of her mother.
The scene starts with two young girls watching a television program featuring a cowboy riding a horse. One of the girls imitates the cowboy by sitting on her pillow and bouncing up and down. Kaplan uses slow motion, dramatic music, the sound of heavy breathing, and close-ups of the child’s face to show the character unknowingly masturbating. The girl falls off her pillow and her mother runs in to take her to the hospital.
Read More: Netflix Fires Director of Communications for ‘Descriptive Use of the N-Word’
Netflix was criticized in a post by Megan Fox for the conservative news site PJ Media . Fox said that she reported the scene to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. “Netflix is in violation of distributing child pornography because the child in question is very clearly engaging in the sexual act of masturbation,” Fox wrote, “and this exceeds the minimum requirement of merely being suggestive.”
Kaplan responded to the backlash with the following statement to IndieWire:
“Despair” is a film. When we see a shark eating a woman on film, no one thinks the woman really died or that the shark was real. We work in a world of fiction; and, for me, before being a director comes being a father.
Of course this scene was filmed using a trick, which was that the girls were copying a cowboy scene from a film by John Ford. The girls never understood what they were doing, they were just copying what they were seeing on the screen. No adult interacted with the girls, other than the child acting coach. Everything was done under the careful surveillance of the girls’ mothers. Because I knew this scene might cause some controversy at some point, there is “Making Of” footage of the filming of the entire scene.
Everything works inside the spectators’ heads, and how you think this scene was filmed will depend on your level of depravity.
“Despair” was released last year in Argentina under its original title, “Desearas: Al Hombre De Tu Hermana.” Netflix first made the film available in December 2017.
Beyond PJ Media, Netflix and the film have received backlash on social media (see embedded tweets below). Netflix has not responded to IndieWire’s requests for comment.
@netflix You need to remove the film Desire from your service IMMEDIATELY. You are MAKING AVAILABLE CHILD PORN by leaving this film up. I am DISGUSTED and will be canceling my service if this is not fixed ASAP. What is wrong with you?!
— Nicole (@NMChampagne) June 27, 2018
@netflix If you don’t remove the child pornography film #Desire from your site, I will be dropping my subscription. This is illegal and you should be ashamed. cc: @DLoesch @ChrisLoesch @jason_howerton @BillyHallowell @mkhammer @RealJamesWoods @LawrenceBJones3
— Dena Berry (@D_R_Berry) June 28, 2018
@netflix I’m curious to know if you guys watch the films you put on your site before you approve them. Because if you guys watched the first 2 min of #desire you wouldn’t of put it on your site. Please remove now it’s disgusting.
— Michael Fritsch (@fritsch34) June 28, 2018
@netflix why does your platform continually promote pedophilia? The Desire movie & months ago with that disgusting cartoon. Canceling sub, and will be getting family too as well Netflix supports pedophiles & pedophila. #teamHulu
— (@dontcalllmejess) June 28, 2018
Watch the first few minutes of the movie Desire from Netflix
promotion of pedophilia absolutely disgusting!! Parents should be arrested for this scene alone!!
— TamiAnn (@TamiAnn02) June 27, 2018
@netflix @FBI @TheJusticeDept Netflix WHY ARE YOU OFFERING KIDDIE PORN??? #Desire @FBI @TheJusticeDept PLEASE investigate
— Vicious St. Bernard (@chrisbo62) June 28, 2018
Additional reporting by Eric Kohn.
Sign Up: Stay on top of the latest breaking film and TV news! Sign up for our Email Newsletters here.
This Article is related to: Film and tagged Desire , Netflix
More From IndieWire
- ‘Iron Fist’ Season 2 Review: Marvel TV’s Least Favorite Superhero Shines Brighter Thanks to His Friends
- ‘Sierra Burgess Is a Loser’ Star Shannon Purser Explains Why Netflix’s Teen Rom-Com Avoids the Genre’s Biggest Tropes
- ‘Outlaw King’ Review: Netflix’s Lame ‘Braveheart’ Spinoff Will Force You to Admit that Mel Gibson Did it Better — TIFF
- ‘Next Gen’: Netflix’s $30-Million Animated Pickup Taps the Sentient Robot Zeitgeist
- ‘It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’: Kaitlin Olson on Working with Mindy Kaling, and Why There’s Less…
- ‘The Predator’ Review: Shane Black’s Sequel Is a Mad Science Experiment that Shouldn’t Have Been Let Out…
- Olivia Munn Says She’s Promoting ‘Predator’ After Sex Offender Casting Because She’s ‘Contractually…
- ‘The Beach Bum’ First Trailer: Harmony Korine Returns to Unleash Matthew McConaughey’s Wild Stoner Side
- Claire Denis, Legendary French Auteur, Saw Every ‘Twilight’ Film and Was ‘Amazed’ by Robert Pattinson…
The 2018 IndieWire TIFF Bible: Every Review, Interview, and News Item Posted During the Festival
‘It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia’: Kaitlin Olson on Working with Mindy Kaling, and Why There’s Less Improv In Season 13
‘Fahrenheit 11/9’: Michael Moore Wants to Shape Midterm Elections With Powerful New Doc — TIFF
Comedy Cellar Owner Says He’s ‘Very Upset’ With Louis C.K. Over Controversial Set: ‘We Don’t Expect Him Back Anytime Soon’
Claire Denis, Legendary French Auteur, Saw Every ‘Twilight’ Film and Was ‘Amazed’ by Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart
Get the latest IndieWire alerts and newsletters delivered directly to your inbox
Welcome to the Telluride Film Festival, Your Oscar Race Crucible
As DGA, PGA and SAG Announce 2020 Awards Dates, Expect Oscar Ripple Effects to Come
25 Awards Contenders to See This Season, From ‘Roma’ to ‘The Favourite’ to ‘First Man’ and More
‘Portlandia’ Star Carrie Brownstein on How ‘Six Feet Under’ Inspired Her To Take Risks on TV — Turn It On Podcast
Also: The story behind her favorite “Portlandia” episode of all time, “The Story of Toni and Candace,” and whether she and Fred Armisen will ever revisit the show.
Emmys: Will ‘Handmaid’s Tale’ Triumph Over ‘Game of Thrones,’ and ‘Atlanta’ Over ‘Mrs. Maisel’? — Screen Talk Emmy Edition
Episode 13: The outstanding drama, comedy, and limited series Emmy races may appear to have their frontrunners, but surprises are possible at next month’s ceremony.
Oscar Season is Imminent, But Don’t Forget About These Smaller Films — IndieWire’s Movie Podcast
There are many exciting movies around the corner, but we already have much to celebrate.
‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ Producer Bruce Miller On How the ‘ER’ Pilot Changed the Way He Writes — Turn It On Podcast
The Emmy-nominated showrunner discusses how 1994’s two-hour “ER” premiere “24 Hours” changed TV. Plus: His favorite “The Handmaid’s Tale” episode.
Criterion’s ‘The Tree of Life’ Is Not a Director’s Cut, but a New Movie From Terrence Malick
Malick says that the new, 188-minute edit of his 2011 drama starring Brad Pitt is another version altogether.
Spike Lee’s Longtime Editor: ‘BlacKkKlansman’ Was His Quickest Cut Since ‘Do the Right Thing’
Barry Alexander Brown tells IndieWire about the pair’s long-time working relationship, the important lesson he took from “Malcolm X,” and discovering that the actual David Duke was in Charlottesville.
‘Madeline’s Madeline’: Why the Dreamy Movie’s Surreal Imagery Took Six Years and Many Experiments to Get Right
How the melding of Josephine Decker and Ashley Connor’s bold visions and experimental backgrounds resulted in one of the year’s most visually astounding films.